Aaron Tveit

John "Maz" Mazello

Tyler Hoechlin

Johnathan "Dells" Dellamonica

Jay Hayden

Vincent "Vinnie" Maltzan

Duke Davis Roberts

Ty Dellamonica

Joseph Mazzello

Pat Murray

Chace Crawford

Arthur Barone

Ryan Pinkston

Jonathan Garvey

Matt Bush

David Stein

Manny Montana

Zapata

Toby Hemingway

Palacco

David Del Rio

Tree

Jim Belushi

Jim

Philip Winchester

Fotch

Michael Fishman

Antonelli

Matt Barr

Anthony

Billy Gardell

Umpire Haze

Michael Consiglio

Dave Schwartz

Justin Matthew Gallegos

Rick Iwasaki

Zachary Scott Green

Anna B. Shaffer

Spectator (uncredited)

Austin Kane

Young Maz